Chatterbox Cheesecake
Chatterbox Cheesecake

Follow us on social for updates.

Welcome to Chatterbox Cheesecake

Our Story

Our Products

Our Products

We're at it again!  Chatterbox and God's provision allowed Pam to stay home when our kids were little.  Now it's Troy's retirement adventure.  We look forward to reconnecting with former friends and meeting new cheesecake lovers!  We wait expectantly to see God at work again through our baking passion.

Our Products

Our Products

Our Products

At Chatterbox Cheesecake, we specialize in New York style cheesecakes.  Our cakes are perfect for your family and business celebrations and occasions.  Our delicious varieties are available in 10 inch, 7 inch, and adorable mini cakes.  Let us help you make your next gathering one to remember!

Cheesceake Varieties

Our Team

Our Products

Our Team

Our team? No, Troy and Pam are, and will continue to be the bakers/creators at Chatterbox Cheesecake.  Our family however will always be a driving force behind what we do.  Our "little ones" grew to become an attorney, teacher, American Sign Language interpreter, and our latest addition, a social media marketer.

Contact Us

We're located at 105 Quinn Circle in Millersburg, Ohio. Call us at 330.403.3058 or drop us a line below!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Subscribe

Sign up to be the first to get updates.

Cheesecake Varieties

The Standard

It may be less flashy, but this cake is anything but plain. Prices: 10 inch - $48, 7 inch - $29, minis - $2.80 ea. (minimum order of 1 dozen per variety)

Classic New York


Deluxe Flavors

These cakes begin with our classic cheesecake but are taken to the next level with your favorite flavorings, cookies, or other unique additions. Prices: 10 inch - $53, 7 inch - $32, minis - $3.10 ea. (minimum order of 1 dozen per variety)

Cookies and Cream

Mint Chocolate Chip

Strawberry Milkshake

Premiere Chocolate

Chocolate Chip

Maple Pumpkin

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

Coconut Cream

Streusel Coffee Cake

White Chocolate


Premium Creations

Homemade caramel, chocolate ganche, and delectable nuts are just some of the additions that take these cakes over the top. Prices: 10 inch - $58, 7 inch - $35, minis - $3.40 ea. (minimum order of 1 dozen per variety)

Salted Caramel Turtle

German Chocolate

Snickers

Reese's Peanut Butter Cup

White Chocolate Raspberry Swirl

Minis unavailable in this variety.

S'mores

Minis $4.00 each.

Tiramisu

Minis $4.00 each.

Toppings and Cutting for Service

Our Homemade Toppings

Prices: 9 oz. - $3.00 12 oz. - $4.00

Strawberry, Blueberry, Red Raspberry*, Lemon, Peanut Butter, Caramel, Choco

*1.00 additional charge


Cutting

If presentation of each piece is important, or if you simply want to save time and the mess, have us precut your cakes for you.

7 inch cakes

$2

Cut into 6 or 8 pieces

10 inch cakes

$4

Cut into 12, 14, or 16 pieces

Indulge in Our Sweet Creations - A Photo Gallery of Chatterbox Cheesecake

Strawberry Milkshake

    Copyright © 2025 Chatterbox Cheesecake - All Rights Reserved.

    Powered by

    This website uses cookies.

    We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

    Accept